The Detroit Pistons could be celebrating a three-peat right now. Kobe would still be behind Shaq and Magic, and Phil would be stuck on nine championships. That is why Darko Milicic is the Biggest Bust in NBA history.
Yes, the Blazers should have picked Jordan over Sam Bowie. But a big part of Bowie being a bust was injuries; he made the NBA All-Rookie team in 1985.
You’re probably thinking, "What about Olowokandi or Kwame Brown?" True, Olowokandi and Brown didn’t have the skill to justify where they were picked, just like Darko. But those guys aren’t even on the same bust planet as Darko. Here's why.
The Clippers and the Wizards were (are?) teams in the dumps because of poor management, drafting, and coaching. Their goal was to get the guy that could have the biggest impact. It was all about potential. Also, can you really call these guys busts when the best players drafted after them were Paul Pierce and Pau Gasol, respectively? It’s not like anyone passed on Jordan.
And no one is knocking Orlando for picking Dwight Howard over Emeka Okafor. Sometimes the gamble for the player with the most potential works out. The worst that can happen is that you’re in the lottery again.
So as crazy as it sounds, the closest parallel to the Darko situation is the Tim Duncan draft of 1997. The Spurs already had a franchise player in David Robinson, but he was injured for most of the year, and San Antonio ended up with the #1 pick. But otherwise, the 1997 Spurs were similar to the 2003 Pistons, in that both teams were in the position to add a top prospect to an established team.
The Spurs, of course, picked Duncan, who would keep that momentum going. They didn’t draft a project. They drafted to win now. Imagine if they had drafted Chauncey Billups (took years to become great), Antonio Daniels (role player), Tony Battie (who?), Ron Mercer (seriously?) or Tim Thomas (slacker-iffic!)?
This is why Darko is the Biggest Bust. Drafting Darko kept the Pistons from repeating in 2005, and getting past the Eastern Conference Finals from 2006 to 2008. Darko is the reason why the Pistons are in the lottery this year.
Imagine the Pistons with Chris Bosh in the middle for the last six years? All of a sudden, the aging of Ben Wallace and the departure of Rasheed Wallace aren’t such big deals. Chauncey Billups might still be running the point.
Imagine the Pistons with D-Wade at shooting guard? Wade would have learned under Rip Hamilton, and then taken the starting SG spot to a whole new level.
Imagine Mr. Offense, Carmelo Anthony, with the two Wallaces and Antonio McDyess at his back?
Key free agents would have come to Detroit to play for championships. These hypothetical Pistons would have rivaled the Cavs, Magic and Celts in the East, and the Lakers and Spurs in the West. These Pistons could have been a dynasty, and entered the pantheon of all-time greatest franchises.
For those of you who agree, should Joe Dumars lose his job for this mistake?
For those of you who don’t agree, who do you think is the Biggest Bust in NBA Draft history?